YouTube Shorts, those bite-sized videos that have captured the attention of users worldwide, offer an excellent way to share information and entertainment. However, sometimes you might want to download a Short as an MP3 file for personal use. But here’s the catch: YouTube doesn’t allow you to freely extract and convert the audio of a Short into an MP3. If you want to do it legally, there are steps you need to follow.
Obtaining the Short URL
First, let’s look at the three common ways that people try to obtain the URL of a YouTube Short. These are:
-
Copy link from the arrow on the right of the Short. This is actually not always going to work. In fact, I’ve found this doesn’t always work.
-
Address bar while the Short is playing.
-
Either youtube.com/shorts or youtube.com/watch.
The URLs will all be in one of these three forms:
Pasting and Converting the Link
Once you copy the public link, however, we’ll need to determine whether that particular Short supports conversion. Once that’s been determined, then proceed to paste the link to the page and select your desired format. For now, I’m only selecting MP3.
You can also extract just the audio of the Short, which can come in handy if you don’t like the video itself. Selecting “audio-only extraction” means that the tool will pull out the sound from the Short and save that to a file. That’s how a third-party converter extracts and encodes the audio, but it isn’t the same thing as YouTube authorizing the download.
Authorization and Legal Rights
What’s important is that you must be authorized to perform any kind of download. What does that mean? It means more than just being able to view that Short inside YouTube; the Service has to authorize the download, or you need prior written permission from YouTube and, if applicable, the rights holder. You may have to accept some terms and conditions. However, there are different levels of permission that apply before you’re able to download any files.
There are two basic concepts about the rights to download something. One is that YouTube Terms specify that what you are doing is considered “personal viewing.” That is, viewing content that belongs to someone else without their express consent.
But if you download and use something without the rights holder explicitly authorizing you to use it, you may violate the law. The alternative, though, is that YouTube gives you access to some of its services with prior written permission — both the rights holders and YouTube. This could include the rights to own or control the content. If that applies to you, then yes, you may make a copy.
Alternatively, there’s the official offline playback where YouTube provides access to certain content via YouTube Premium. There’s also Creative Commons-licensed content, provided the conditions of that license are satisfied. Fair use is context specific, but generally isn’t considered a blanket permission.
Making a copy of an authorized MP3, however, is not a reuse license. Reusing the audio for another project would require explicit permission, or a license of some sort. A separate video rights and audio rights issue would apply, too. If you don’t have explicit permission, or if the video/audio has specific licensing conditions (such as Creative Commons), you probably shouldn’t use it elsewhere.
Bitrate options
In terms of MP3 quality, the converter may offer several different choices of bitrate. Here are the options shown in the converter menu.
64k
96k
128k (default)
192k
256k
320k
This is the highest MP3 output setting in the converter’s menu, not necessarily the highest audio stream actually served by YouTube for every Short.
It’s important to note, however, that higher doesn’t necessarily mean lossless. In reality, the available audio depends on what was uploaded and how YouTube processed it; the sources reviewed do not establish a fixed 64k-or-128k range for YouTube Shorts streams, and the converter’s listed bitrates are output choices, not proof that the source contains that much audio data. It also doesn’t guarantee a lossless source audio. In addition, you won’t find true 320k quality in every Short. So don’t assume the quality is going to improve automatically when you choose a higher-quality setting. Instead, check the settings that your converter allows you to use. If none of them appeal to you, you’ll have to settle for whatever your choice offers.
Failed links
I’ve run into quite a few problems over the years trying to extract YouTube audio using various tools. Sometimes, it’s simply because the link that you copied wasn’t the correct link, or because it didn’t match the supported URL structure that the tool recognizes. In such cases, recopy the public link, then use a supported URL form, and see whether it works.
Other times, I’ve seen links fail because I tried to bypass YouTube’s access or permission limits by using another tool. But that’s not going to fix the problem.
If it fails, then it fails. And you need to stop. Just because you don’t understand why the audio failed doesn’t mean that it’s okay to attempt to circumvent access or permissions limitations.
Fallback paths
If it fails, then it fails. There aren’t many other alternatives.
However, there are safer fallback paths. First, try official offline playback where possible. Alternatively, ask the rights holder directly for direct permission. Or, if possible, get lawfully licensed audio.
And remember, even though we’ve gone through the trouble of downloading and converting an MP3 from a YouTube Short, that doesn’t grant you the right to redistribute the audio publicly, regardless of the original content.